in

Barry Jenkins’ ‘The Underground Railroad’ Is a Sprawling, Overwhelming American Epic: TV Review

Every single frame of “The Underground Railroad” is haunted.

Ghosts of horrors past, present and future linger at the story’s edges, flicker in and out with eerie ease. People alive, dead and somewhere in between stare into the camera with quiet, solemn clarity. Whispers fade into the background, sharing terrible secrets as urgent prayer. In adapting Colson Whitehead’s novel to the television screen, Barry Jenkins has molded something harrowing, emotional and almost too big to take in all at once.

The entirety of “The Underground Railroad” — 10 episodes altogether, most running at least a full hour — will be available upon its May 14 premiere on Amazon Prime, but that is a mistake. The series is dense enough that each episode would, and should, stand on their own with enough space for viewers to digest it before moving on to the next. Instead, Amazon is releasing all of them in one fell swoop, making it far too easy for someone to muscle through too much without reprieve, or else shy away from the show entirely should it get too challenging. It’s hard not to imagine how “Underground Railroad” would fare if it were to unfold weekly, giving each installment a more lasting spotlight.

If you do blaze through the series, you might as well take the advice of one of its conductors. As he helps runaway slave Cora (Thuso Mbedu) into an underground freight train — Whitehead’s invention that makes the historical euphemism for the South to North escape network vibrantly literal — the conductor sees her incredulous expression and tips his hat. “Just look out at the sides as you speed through,” he says, “and you’ll see the true face of America.”

Over the course of her incredible, awful journey, Cora becomes a reluctant living witness to America’s worst ills, only slightly reimagined by Whitehead for emphasis. She begins as a cotton picker in Georgia, subject to the whims of her sadistic master (Benjamin Walker) whose name she bears. Her mother Mabel (Sheila Atim) was one of the only runaway slaves for miles who ever truly got away from career slavecatchers like Ridgeway (Joel Edgerton), escaping in the dead of night when Cora was still a child. Mabel looms large over Cora’s story, a mythic and strange figure in her daughter’s furious, determined mind.

From Georgia, Cora runs with Caesar (Aaron Pierre) to South Carolina, where a seemingly civilized utopia reveals its rotten foundation. In North Carolina, Cora tucks herself away in an attic with Grace (Mychal-Bella Bowman), another exhausted stowaway, because the entire state has outlawed Black people unless they’re hanging from trees as a warning. Tennessee is a gnarled wasteland of burning brush while Indiana is its tantalizing opposite, too green and good to be true. The dread of each state and the unbearable lessons they teach Cora are unique unto themselves, terrible and true.

As with any work of adaptation, it’s fascinating to understand where Jenkins and his writers saw fit to linger versus what they decided to slim down from the page to the screen. Realizing that the Carolinas each only get a single episode is initially confusing, but these chapters end up being two of the show’s smartest, maybe because they had these limits. Other sections — like Cora’s trek through Tennessee and a lengthy flashback to Ridgeway’s youth, of all people — could have used the same editorial eye. It makes sense that Jenkins would have wanted more time than a film could have allowed to tell Whitehead’s story, but the organization of these ten episodes end up making an argument for eight.

With each new state, community and enemy, Cora learns the visceral price of American racism as it chips away at her resolve and everything she loves, or could love if given a real chance to. Without the inside perspective Whitehead’s novel affords Cora by telling the story largely through her eyes, Mbedu has an astonishingly difficult job in conveying the nuances of her thoughts throughout the series, which does lose some of her prickly pragmatism as portrayed in the book. As much as “Underground Railroad” is about Cora, it’s also about everyone she encounters throughout her fight for freedom, and there’s only so much Mbedu can do to mitigate that as everything crashes down around Cora for good.

And as sharp as Edgerton is as the itinerant Ridgeway, giving the slavecatcher one of the few extended flashbacks becomes an especially confusing choice as we meet so many others whose backstories would have enriched the text even more. Pierre’s Caesar is exactly the convincing, grounding force that character must be, even when he becomes more of a memory than a person; William Jackson Harper brings a steady, sympathetic hand to the role of freed man Royal; Amber Gray makes every minute she gets hopeful and, inevitably, heart-wrenching. The show’s biggest scene-stealer might also be its smallest: As Ridgeway’s loyal henchman Homer, 11-year-old Chase Dillon doesn’t need many lines to expose his character’s twisted insides, but I would have been very intrigued by an entire chapter about how he yoked himself to this miserable white man in the first place.

Jenkins, who developed the series and directed all 10 episodes, threads the story’s inherent trauma with moments of human intimacy that bring an extra dimension of care to a show that could have been unbearably brutal. There is pain, and so much of it, teeming out the faces of every Black person eyed by Jenkins’ camera. (The first Georgia episode in which Cora and her fellow slaves’ everyday realities are laid bare is particularly rough, so consider this your fair warning.) But there are also times when the series will eschew the norm of onscreen stories of slaves by having someone describe an atrocity rather than show it in gruesome detail, recognizing that the fact of it is disturbing enough.

Jenkins, alongside cinematographer James Laxton, makes sure to find the human tenderness at the heart of every inhumane terror. Romance bursts forth from the unlikeliest places, swelling and sweet. For every hard stare, there is a soft gaze. And as with every Jenkins project, the sonic atmosphere of nature and music quickly becomes as important as the visual language of colors and close-ups. The background hums with cicadas and rustling leaves; when Cora finds the time to breathe, Nicholas Britell’s eerie score resolves into major keys as if sighing with relief right with her.

Not everyone will want to devote 10 hours to watching America’s worst instincts come to grisly fruition, no matter how thoughtfully told — which is fair, especially if you’re Black and understand them all too well. But those who join Cora and Jenkins on this exploration may find themselves enveloped in a story about slaves told unlike many others: one which doesn’t shy away from its truth, but which nevertheless has the compassion to make its suffering more three-dimensional than the shock of a scream.

“The Underground Railroad” premieres Friday, May 14 on Amazon Prime.

Written by kinq

Vincent Chin Limited Series in Development at Amazon Studios (EXCLUSIVE)

‘Selena’ Stars on Show’s Depiction of Icon’s Death: ‘It Doesn’t Need to Be Gratuitous’